Two American Novels New to Our Shelves: Fitzgerald or Hemingway?

Rosemary Hoyt wants an invitation. Robert Jordan needs help blowing up a bridge. These two newcomers make an unlikely pair, but following them into unfamiliar company is a fine way to choose between two recent additions to our shelves.

Tender Is the Night for the reader who watches the room

On the French Riviera, young film actress Rosemary notices a group of beachgoers who seem entirely at ease with one another. Dick and Nicole Diver are at the centre. Part of the pleasure of reading F. Scott Fitzgerald is how quickly Rosemary’s curiosity becomes our own. Before we know much about the Divers, we too would like to sit under their umbrella.

Try keeping an eye on Dick whenever a conversation starts to drag. Who gets drawn back in? Who needs rescuing from an awkward remark? Once you notice how much work goes into making a gathering feel effortless, the marriage at the centre of Tender Is the Night begins to look different.

For Whom the Bell Tolls for the reader who watches the clock

Ernest Hemingway sends Robert Jordan, an American fighting on the Republican side in the Spanish Civil War, into the mountains with orders to destroy a bridge. The assignment sounds straightforward on paper. In the guerrillas’ camp, Jordan meets the people who will still have to live with its consequences after the bridge comes down.

Listen to the first disagreements about the operation. Jordan can measure the structure and calculate the explosives. Pilar and Pablo know the people, the horses and the ground. As the attack approaches, even a conversation over food can change your estimate of whether the plan will work.

Which one should your book club open first?

Choose Fitzgerald if your group enjoys disagreeing about the meaning of a gesture. Choose Hemingway if a decision with a deadline usually gets everyone talking. For a paired reading, bring one question to both books: when does the newcomer first understand what belonging to this group will cost?

Start on the beach with Tender Is the Night, or follow Jordan into the mountains in For Whom the Bell Tolls.

Back to blog

Leave a comment